Open MRI vs Closed MRI: What’s the Difference and Why It Matters

When your doctor utters an MRI, things become scary. But when the next question arises, “open MRI or close MRI,” the picking indeed becomes daunting.

So, open MRI vs closed MRI: which can accurately answer your complex condition?

The answer depends on your diagnostic needs and your comfort level.

Open MRI vs closed MRI differ in their design and functionality. While open MRIs feature a spacious and open design and prioritize patient comfort, closed MRIs feature a fully enclosed tunnel offering superior image quality for complex diagnostics.

This article will explore the differences between open and closed MRI systems, as well as their advantages and challenges.

What are MRI Techniques?

Magnetic Resonance Imaging, aka MRI, is a powerful diagnostic tool that uses strong magnetic fields, radio waves, and advanced computer technology to create detailed images of the body.

It exploits the properties of hydrogen atoms in your body’s water to create images of soft tissues, such as the brain, muscles, and joints.

The heart of MRI techniques is a powerful magnet, ranging from 0.5 to 3.0 Tesla, that generates the magnetic field. It aligns the hydrogen protons within your body in one direction, like a compass needle pointing toward the Earth’s magnetic field.

The MRI machines then emit short bursts of radiofrequency energy that disturb the proton alignments, temporarily knocking the protons out of their original positions.

When the pulse stops, the protons return to their original positions and realign with the magnetic field. Relaxed protons emit energy signals that the MRI machine detects. Its computer then processes these signals and converts them into cross-sectional images.

Medicai makes the imaging process a breeze by allowing real-time data sharing and secure cloud PACS storage. Clinicians can quickly access imaging results, enabling them to make faster, smarter decisions.

MRI is beneficial for

• Neurological diagnosis: brain tumors, strokes, multiple sclerosis, etc
• Musculoskeletal imaging: ligament tears, cartilage damage, spinal abnormalities, etc.
• Oncology monitoring: tumor growth or response to treatment
• Cardiology: heart structure and vascular health

MRI comes in two types, open MRI and closed MRI, each with some distinct features.

What Is An Open MRI?

The open MRI is a patient-centered design with open slides or a wider gap. Its less restrictive design offers a comfortable environment for patients with confined-space issues, such as those in a closed MRI.

Open MRI systems are effective for routine imaging, including-

• Musculoskeletal scans: Examining larger structures like bones and major joints.
• Pediatric imaging: Providing a less scary experience for children.
• Geriatric patients: Accommodating mobility challenges and ensuring easier positioning.
• Obesity or Bariatric needs: Furnishing a comfy solution for larger people.

What Does an Open MRI Look Like?

Open MRI scanners feature open sides or a wide C-shaped structure, providing more space around the patient than traditional closed MRI tunnels. Instead of being completely enclosed, patients lie between two magnetic plates — one above and one below — while the sides remain open.

This design helps reduce anxiety, especially for those with claustrophobia, obesity, or pediatric needs. The open space allows for easier breathing, communication with technicians, and even limited movement during longer scans.

What Is a Closed MRI?

A closed MRI is the traditional design containing a cylindrical tunnel. The patients lie on a table that slides into the machines. The closed MRI design can maximize image quality using strong magnetic fields and advanced imaging technology.

Closed MRI can assess several conditions effectively, including-

• Brain and Spinal Imaging: Detecting minor abnormalities like brain lesions, nerve compression, or herniated discs.
• Cardiac Imaging: Assessing heart structures, blood flow, and vascular abnormalities.
• Orthopedic Scans: joint damage, ligament tears, and cartilage degeneration.
• Oncology: Identifying tumors and monitoring their progression.

What Does a Closed MRI Machine Look Like?

A closed MRI machine resembles a long, cylindrical tunnel (also called a bore). Patients slide into the narrow tube, which contains a powerful magnet that produces high-resolution images.
While the enclosed design may feel intimidating to some, it delivers stronger image quality due to higher magnetic field strength (1.5 T to 3 T).

Open MRI vs Closed MRI: The Key Differences

What do you need – an open MRI or a closed MRI?

To figure it out, you must know how these systems differ in design, functionality, and result. So, let’s check out the differences between open MRI and closed MRI.

Design and Structure

The design of an open MRI is less restrictive, featuring open sides or a wide gap above the patient. The machine is usually C or U-shaped, creating a more spacious and less confining environment. Thus, you have better visibility during the scan.

However, the magnets in open MRI are a bit weaker. They range from 0.3 to 1.2 Tesla. So, open MRI machine images may have some clarity issues, lacking the fine details like the closed MRI.

Closed MRI, on the other hand, produces remarkably detailed images. It features powerful magnets ranging between 1.5 and 3 Tesla. The machine’s cylindrical tunnel fully encloses the patient, which may feel a bit tight and confined.

However, modern closed MRI machines have better ventilation, mirrors, and calming lighting that can help you feel more at ease during imaging.

Image Quality

Open MRI has lower magnetic field strength. So, the images of open MRI machines lack the ultra-high precision that you need for more complex diagnoses. Open MRI works effectively for less complex cases, like scanning for larger injuries or monitoring chronic conditions.

However, even with slightly lower-resolution images, Medicai’s updated platform ensures healthcare providers can make accurate and timely decisions.

On the other hand, closed MRI offers superior image clarity than open MRI images, thanks to its powerful magnets. It creates sharp, precise images required for high-resolution imaging conditions like a small tumor, brain lesions, cartilage damage, joint evaluations, etc.

Open MRI vs Closed MRI Image Quality

While both technologies use magnetic resonance, closed MRI scanners generally produce higher-resolution images due to stronger magnets.
However, modern high-field open MRI machines (up to 1.2 T) have narrowed the gap considerably.

Patient Comfort

MRI can indeed create concerns about comfort. Unlike the CT scan, you may need to remain still for a long time for some scans.

Thanks to its shape, the open MRI machine offers a more relaxed environment. You can see your surroundings during the scan, which comforts and calms you.

Also, the open slides and wide gap are more accessible and comfortable for taller or larger patients, for whom an open MRI is especially suitable.

• Children who get scared in a closed MRI
• Larger patients who may not fit in a closed MRI
• Those with mobility challenges

On the other hand, the enclosed design of a closed MRI, with its narrow tunnel and loud knocking sound, can make you feel confined or uncomfortable. It’s especially struggling for people with claustrophobia, which can increase their anxiety.

However, many facilities now offer noise-canceling headphones or video goggles to distract and comfort patients.

Scan Duration

Open MRI takes longer to complete a scan because of its weak magnetic fields. Depending on the complexity, a scan can last 30 to 60 minutes, sometimes more.

On the contrary, closed MRIs are faster, and all credit goes to their strong magnetic fields. A standard scan usually takes 15 to 45 minutes, depending on the diagnosis.

Medicai provides integrated, secure cloud storage with advanced sharing capabilities to preserve the scans. The user-friendly portals make it easy for you and healthcare providers to quickly view and share imaging records.

Cost

Open MRIs cost less than closed MRIs because of their simpler technology and lower magnetic field. Closed MRIs, on the other hand, feature advanced technology, higher magnetic field strength, and superior image quality, which make the imaging expensive.

A closed MRI scan usually costs $1,200 to $4,000, depending on the imaged area and complexity. However, most insurance plans cover closed MRI scans.

Is Open MRI More Expensive?

Open MRI exams can sometimes cost 10 – 20 percent more than closed MRIs because:

• The scanners operate at lower field strengths, requiring longer image acquisition times.
• Fewer facilities have open MRI machines, which may affect scheduling and pricing.

Wide-Bore vs Open MRI: What’s the Difference?

Many patients confuse wide-bore MRIs with open MRIs.

• Wide-bore MRI: A larger tunnel (up to 70 cm) within a traditional closed design, offering more space while maintaining high-field strength (1.5 T–3 T).
• Open MRI: Fully open sides with lower magnetic strength (0.3 T–1.2 T).

Both aim to reduce claustrophobia, but wide-bore MRIs deliver closed-MRI-level image clarity with improved comfort.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Open MRI

Let’s look at the pros and cons of picking an open MRI.

Advantages

• It enhances comfort, reduces anxiety, and provides a more relaxed experience for children, larger patients, and people with claustrophobia.
• It offers easy accessibility, especially for patients with special needs or the elderly.
• The reduced noise levels provide a less intimidating environment for noise-sensitive patients.
• Open MRI scans are more affordable.

Disadvantages

• Open MRI images are not high-quality, as the weaker magnetic field may not capture fine details.
• It takes longer, making you stay still for a long time.
• Open MRI machines may not be available in all areas.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Closed MRI

Closed MRI comes with both benefits and challenges.

Advantages

• The powerful magnets of a closed MRI machine produce detailed, high-resolution, precise images that can detect small abnormalities, such as tiny tumors or cartilage damage.
• Closed MRI scans take less time because of their powerful magnetic fields.
• Closed MRI machines are widely available in most imaging centers and hospitals.

Disadvantages

• The enclosed tunnel of closed MRI machines can feel overwhelming for patients with claustrophobia or anxiety.
• The machines make loud knocking sounds during scans that can be distressful for many.
• Patients with larger body sizes or mobility limitations may not fit comfortably in a closed MRI machine.
• Closed MRI scans are expensive because of their advanced technology and higher magnetic strength.

Open MRI vs Closed MRI: Choosing the Right MRI for Your Needs

Open MRI or Closed MRI – the decision usually depends on your medical conditions, complexity, and comfort.

When To Choose Open MRI

Open MRI prioritizes comfort. So, it is ideal for

• Claustrophobic patients
• Children
• Larger people
• People with mobility challenges

However, an open MRI may not provide the higher detail and resolution as a closed MRI. It is effective for general imaging, such as monitoring chronic conditions or assessing larger abnormalities that don’t require ultra-high precision.

When To Choose a Closed MRI

A closed MRI is ideal when you need the highest level of detail, resolution, and precision.

• Brain and neurological disorders
• Spinal conditions
• Cardiac imaging
• Orthopedic Injuries

Whether you undergo an open or closed MRI, Medicai ensures your images and reports are securely stored and accessible in real time. This eliminates delays, allowing your doctor to promptly review and discuss the findings.

Open MRI for Brain and Spine Imaging

Open MRI systems can successfully image the brain, spine, and joints, though they may not capture subtle lesions or microvascular structures as precisely as a closed MRI.

For high-detail neuro or vascular studies, 3 T closed MRI scanners remain the gold standard.
For musculoskeletal, pediatric, or anxious patients, open MRIs offer a better experience without compromising routine diagnostic quality.

Conclusion

Open MRI vs Closed MRI – making the right choice for you doesn’t have to be daunting.

Closed MRIs provide unmatched image clarity for precise diagnostics, while open MRIs prioritize patient comfort and accessibility. It depends on your conditions, your comfort, and the complexity.

Medicai ensures the process is smooth regardless of which MRI your doctor recommends. We make your MRI journey smooth, secure, and integrated, from securely storing your images to timely data sharing.